THE BEST CHRISTMAS PAGEANT EVER

a film by Dallas Jenkins released through Lionsgate in 2024

A film with an 'in-period' setting is extremely problematic—especially with a limited budget.  The Best Christmas Pageant Ever, though based on a novel by Barbara Robinson published in 1972, would do better to ignore its roots—the resultant present-day coda adds nothing to the story.

The child casting is brilliant, but the adult casting is barely adequate.  Still, the dialogue is occasionally witty, and the staple pre-climax confrontation scene (that clears the air between the main characters before the final challenge is met) is the best one in the film, ably managed by the child leads. 

We're left with a fitfully amusing tale making very important points with not a hint of subtlety.

★★☆☆☆

Best for ages 9+

FEATURING

JUDY GREER, PETE HOLMES, MOLLY BELLE WRIGHT, AND LAUREN GRAHAM

 

© 2025 Ian C. Bloom